What impact did the Mayflower Compact and the Fundamental Orders have on Colonial America?

(Acknowledgment: The following is the preface and edited version of the Fundamental Orders from Living American Documents, selected and edited by Isidore Starr, Lewis Paul Todd, and Merle Curti, ©1961 Harcourt, Brace & Co., inc.)

"The British people do not have a written constitution. They have an "unwritten" constitution composed of customs, traditions, and the important documents such as their Magna Carta and their Bill of Rights.

Some of the Englishmen who settled in the American colonies, including the men who founded the colony of Connecticut in 1636, did not have much faith in this approach to government. Unpleasant memories of recent authoritarian acts by England's rulers prompted the Connecticut settlers to put their plan of government into writing.

The Fundamental Orders of Connecticut was the first written constitution in America. Whereas the Mayflower Compact was a general statement in favor of majority rule and government in the interest of the common welfare, the Fundamental Orders set up a detailed scheme of government in which the sovereign power rested with the freemen. No mention was made of the king.

This document was a step in the direction of present-day democracy in that it set the example of a written constitution as the basis of government - a constitution which could be read and understood by all and which could not be changed by the will of one man or a small group."

East Hampton was a confederated township within the colony of Connecticut from 1657 until 1666 when it was brought into the colony of New York (under protest) by the Nicholls pattent. The town citizens of East Hampton cherished the liberties which they exercised within the colony of Connecticut. The MFOP, as the trustee corporation of Montauk, is a direct descendant of the town government of East Hampton at that time. We are intent on asserting and exercising these same fundamental rights and purposes as put forth in this document. Many of the principles of governance contained within the Fundamental Orders are to be incorporated in the Articulated Rights and Constitution of the MFOP/Montauk Trustee Corporation.

See: The Society of Coloial Wars in the State of Connecticut for a full version of the Fundamental Orders and other info.

Introduction

“We, whose names are underwritten … enact, constitute, and frame such just and equall laws, ordinances, acts, constitutions and offices … as shall be thought most meete and convenient for the generall good of the Colonie…”

Explanation

These lines are from the Mayflower Compact, which was written to preserve unity and address tensions between the factions on the ship the Mayflower. 

Mayflower Compact

English settlers on the Mayflower wrote the Mayflower Compact in 1620. It established principles of self-government, common consent, and unity in the colony. 

The History

In 1620, 102 men, women, and children arrived on the shores of Massachusetts. They had traveled from England and had received a charter from the Virginia Company to settle near the Hudson River, which was, at that time, part of Virginia. Harsh storms, however, forced them to anchor in Massachusetts instead, outside of Virginia Company territory.

Of the 102 settlers, 41 were Pilgrims, or members of a Puritan sect called the Separatists, who wished to break away from the Church of England and form independent congregations. The Pilgrims hoped to practice religion more freely in the New World. The rest of the settlers were common people, including merchants, craftsmen, indentured servants, and orphans. 

Once the settlers anchored in Massachusetts, tensions between the two factions began to grow. The non-Pilgrims argued that the Virginia Company contract was void because they were outside of its jurisdiction. Some individuals threatened to leave the group and set out on their own. Leaders knew they needed to unite the settlers and provide a basic framework for self-governance in the absence of any other laws or rules. The document they wrote eventually came to be known as the Mayflower Compact. 

Although it is unclear exactly who wrote the Mayflower Compact, historians usually give university-educated Pilgrim William Brewster credit. The document is short - only 200 words long - and outlines fundamental principles rather than specifics. The Compact explains that the colonists would write and enact “laws, ordinances, acts, constitutions, and offices … for the general good of the colony.” The colonists would be bound to those laws, and would additionally pledge to work together to build a single society. Additionally, the Compact established that the colonists would adhere to the Christian faith. 

Though the Mayflower Compact was not a constitution and did not resolve the legal issues of settling outside of the Virginia Company’s jurisdiction, it was an essential step in establishing self-government in the colony. The Compact was signed by nearly all the adult male passengers on the Mayflower, including two indentured servants. 

Why Care?

The Mayflower Compact was in effect until 1691, when the settlers’ Plymouth Colony joined the Massachusetts Bay Colony. The Compact has been credited with helping the colonists survive their first brutal winter; it helped preserve unity and ensured that the colonists stood by their mission and each other. It also provided a government framework that maintained order and civil society in the absence of any other legal documents.

Additionally, the Compact was the first document establishing self-government written in the New World. It marked an early push for democratic government and was important in cementing ideals of self-government and common consent in America. Many believe it influenced both the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution.

What impact did the Mayflower Compact have?

What impact do you think the Mayflower Compact and the Fundamental Orders of Connecticut had on the creation of the United States government?

What did the Mayflower Compact and the Fundamental Orders have in common?

What was the long term impact of the Mayflower Compact?