Best desktop computer for engineering students
The Best Computers for CAD Design and Engineering in 2020Mark Harris | Created: October 2, 2020 | Updated: November 7, 2020 Last year I wrote about buying a laptop or components to build a desktop computer but did not cover pre-built computers. This year we have updated those articles and are also going to be looking at the best pre-built computers for CAD design, engineering, and hardware development in general. While building a computer for CAD yourself is going to allow you to use the latest technologyand get the best value for your money - a pre-built computer from a global brand will typically offer you excellent support and a warranty. For a business, the ability to simply unbox a computer, install software and start using it has a lot of merits. Show
In this years computer build guide, we were looking at the latest generation of processors and graphics cards. Many systems on this list are still utilising the previous generation. The performance cost is fairly minor compared to the latest generation of the same model. However, it is something you should be aware of. You can also upgrade these systems to newer hardware. Computers for CAD, Design, and Engineering RequirementsI have researched workstations and gaming computers to bring you this short list of computers which I consider to be the best computers for CAD design and engineering work. The key criteria to make a list were:
Nice to haves include a case with multiple USB 3.0 connectors as well as audio connectors on the front panel and lots of USB ports on the back. Engineers, especially electronics engineers, tend to have a whole lot of USB devices plugged into their computers at once! I have every port on my computer full, plus 8 ports of USB hub maxed out if Im debugging hardware. I also ruled out options that were significantly higher priced than competing brands which offered the same or better specifications so you can see the best value. Some brands have some incredibly stylish designs for their cases without much of interest inside. When comparing options for pre-built computers it's best to ignore the marketing literature and jump straight to the specifications list so you can directly compare options based on their performance and value, and only once you have done so look at the aesthetics of the case. Out of all the computers I could find that looked even remotely usable for engineering applications, I have narrowed the results down to a shortlist of 10 potential candidates, presented in no particular order. None of these computers come with a display or any peripherals; those are an added expense and should be chosen to best suit your requirements and needs. DELL XPS Tower Special Edition - $2,994.00XPS Desktop Special EditionOne of the first things I noticed about this case was the picture showing it with the case open. It looks very tidy and should make future RAM or storage upgrades pretty easy if you need it. A previous generation processor powers it, but the processor is one of the higher-end options. The XPS line of computers is very business-oriented, and whilst not specifically designed as a CAD computer, it offers good value for money by comparison as it has a gaming graphics card rather than an NVIDIA Quadro. The Quadro cards are essential if your simulation or CAD software requires ISV certified components, but you pay a lot more for the same performance compared to an NVIDIA RTX series. For this computer, I specified the NVIDIA Geforce RTX 2070 over the Radeon, as its only a little more expensive and most CAD software understands NVIDIA CUDA cores better. CUDA is a fairly well established and mature technology, whereas the Radeon cores are newer and less widely implemented at this point in time.If you dont need much graphics power (such as for Altium Designer® use only), then consider the next computer option, without the more powerful/expensive graphics card that the Special Edition is offered with. With the spec as priced, the system has 64GB of RAM, as well as a 2TB NVMe PCIe SSD, which should give you plenty of high-speed storage and the ability to run almost any engineering application without having your system slow down because it is paging data from memory to disk.
DELL XPS Tower - $2,629.00DELL XPS TowerThis is virtually the same computer as above other than the fact its not a special edition. It comes with the same 8 core Intel Core i9 9900 processor, but it is a lower cost option due to the NVIDIA RTX 2060 graphics card, which is a step down from the NVIDIA RTX 2070 above. The 2060 is more than sufficient for Altium as well as CAD models in Solidworks or Fusion 360/Inventor that are not complex assemblies. You also get the same 64GB of RAM and NVMe storage as the special edition above.
HP Z2 Tower G4 Workstation - $1,629.00HP Z2 Tower G4 WorkstationOur first HP system is a workstation computer, meaning it comes with a Quadro graphics card. While it is cheaper than the XPS systems, it does come with a slower Intel Core i7 9700 processor, much less RAM, less storage space and a significantly slower NVIDIA Quadro graphics card. The key selling point for this computer, for some users at least, will be the ISV certified NVIDIA Quadro P2200 graphics card. This card might make some engineering and simulation software happy and unlock certain features/capabilities in the software. However, in reality, it is a much older and less capable graphics card than the NVIDIA RTX series we see in the two Dell options. The Quadro is based on a GPU core that is two generations behind the RTX series. This means the card has about 50-60% less performance than the NVIDIA RTX 2060. This level of performance is perfectly fine for Altium Designer and moderate complexity MCAD models, but I wouldnt want to be using it for rendering graphics or video. If you need a low-cost ISV certified system for your CAD applications, the HP Z2 Tower G4 might be a great option for you. However, if ISV certification is not required (such as for Altium Designer), you can get better value for money without the NVIDIA Quadro P2200.
HP Z8 G4 Workstation - $4,699.00HP Z8 G4 WorkstationOur next HP workstation is a very powerful option. This is built for high-performance CAD, Engineering and simulation work, though I would love to see it with at least twice as much RAM.Despite the slower clock speed per core, the Intel Xeon Silver outperforms the Intel Core i9-9900 from the Dell computers by 20-25% in benchmarks. The Intel Xeon processor is built for workstation loads, with 16 cores and 32 hyper threads it's capable of some serious multitasking. The individual core speeds are not particularly high due to the large number of cores on the processor - so if your work primarily requires single-thread performance, it might not be the best option. That being said, most engineering applications which need a lot of processing power will take full advantage of the extra cores. The number of cores make this a great workstation for simulation and mechanical CAD work. While the previous HP systems Quadro graphics card was lackluster in performance, the Z8 model features a current generation of Quadro with the NVIDIA Quadro RTX 4000. The RTX 4000 is about halfway between the NVIDIA RTX 2060 and RTX 2070 Super seen in the two Dell computers on this list.With a Xeon processor and Quadro graphics card, this system is going to satisfy even the most demanding simulation software in terms of computer hardware. Both the CPU and GPU are ISV certified and will allow engineering applications to unlock their full potential. Finally, this system can be configured for two processors, giving you even more multithreading capabilities and the ability to run a second graphics card at full speed. Overall, this system is the most powerful in the list and is the best option for serious simulation/rendering/calculation loads.
HP ENVY Desktop - TE01-0175xt - $1,199.99HP ENVY DesktopTying with the next option for the cheapest computer for CAD and engineering on this list, the HP Envy is a great option for students and those on a budget. If you can afford a little extra, the MSI Trident 3 could be an even better option, however. The graphics card in the HP Envy is a step down from the NVIDIA RTX we saw earlier, yet a step up from the HP Z2 G4s Quadro. The Intel Core i7-9700 is the same as seen in the Z2 G4, as is the 16GB of RAM. I love the huge number of USB ports, as well as the SD Card reader on the front. Youll find four more USB 2.0 ports on the back. I love the fact that the higher speed USB ports are on the front, allowing easy access to high-speed USB flash drives or external storage you can plug right in. The PCIe NVME SSD storage is a little lacking in space, at only 256GB. With the OS and a typical complement of software, it will not leave you with a lot of room to keep your engineering project files on the fastest storage on the computer. You would see a massive performance penalty to file load times and transfer speeds if they were put on the 2TB mechanical disk that is also in the system. The front 3.1 Gen 1 USB ports make up for this lack to some degree, allowing you to conveniently plug in some high-speed USB 3 SSD storage to the front of the computer for storing project files. The 3.1 ports offer a higher performance option than the mechanical hard drive - but still significantly slower than the PCIe NVMe drive.
HP Pavilion Gaming - TG01-0185t - $1,199.99HP Pavilion GamingThe final HP system on the list appears to be an identical system to the HP ENVY system, the only difference being the styling on the front panel. If youre looking for a budget computer that can handle moderately demanding engineering software and PCB design software, either of these options would be a good choice - its just a matter of choice on the styling.
MSI Prestige P100 9th - $2,499.00MSI Prestige P100 9thThe MSI Prestige is sold as a Creator system designed for creative professionals. It certainly offers considerable value. The processor is the same that is in the Dell models, making it one of the more powerful systems on the list. The 32GB of RAM is less than the Dell, however the graphics card is also significantly more powerful. The actual configuration will depend on where you buy it, however the configuration listed below makes this a very competitively priced pre-built computer with a lot of power.This system is going to be one of the best value for money computers on this list and suitable for most users. The system also comes with a good number of USB ports on the rear, plus 3 on the front side despite its small form factor.
MSI MEG Trident X 10th - $3,299.00MSI MEG Trident XThe MSI MEG Trident X has only just been released, most stores I found are only offering pre-orders at this point. It comes with the new version of the Intel Core i9-9900K seen in other systems on this list, giving it a performance edge. The Graphics card is also one of the most powerful on this list. For the price above you will get 64GB of RAM and a 1TB PCIe NVMe SSD giving you plenty of memory and storage. Im a big fan of the multiple USB 3.2 Gen 1 ports on the front panel, as well as having a moderate number of USB ports on the back.
MSI Trident 3 10th - $1,499.00MSI Trident 3The MSI Trident offers a current-generation Intel Core i7-10700 processor for a very budget oriented price. While the low-cost HP systems are great for budget-oriented engineers or students, if you can afford a little extra, the MSI Trident will offer you much value for money. The NVIDIA GeForce RTX 2060 Super is a step up from the lowest end option in the NVIDIA RTX series, despite the lowest-end option still being a powerful graphics card. I would love to have seen a few more USB 3.2 ports, and one very disappointing feature is the single HDMI output for a display, meaning you can only have one display on the computer. Many engineers like to have two or more displays to allow them to have datasheets or other documentation on one screen with their primary screen being used for work. With that being said, if youre looking for a compact computer that offers a lot of value for money, the Trident 3 has a lot going for it.
Origin M-Class - $2,450.00Origin M-ClassOrigin allows you to fully specify a computer build, using the same components you could buy if you were doing a DIY build allowing you access to the latest and greatest components. I built up a mid-range computer with their online configuration tool, a very easy experience. I was impressed with the value for money offered, with my design being for a mid-high end system that sits around the midpoint of other systems in this list. Because of the online configurator, the choice of components is completely transparent. Origin shows the make and model of each component, which for me, offers a much better experience than Dells online configuration tools, for example. By being able to see the exact components, I can compare benchmarks for that part to see if it offers high performance. The SSD selection list, for example, is fairly substantial and not all SSDs are made equal - the lowest cost PCIe NVMe SSDs on the market are significantly slower than the highest speed options on the market. Despite building a mid-range computer, I did specifically use a higher-end CPU as the price jump wasnt particularly large for the performance gain.One feature that makes this build stand out from every other computer listed above is the fact that this system has water cooling. The Corsair H100i Pro XT water cooling will allow the CPU to run at its turbo boost speed for longer than the stock cooler and also operate at a much lower volume. Im not particularly fond of constant fan noise, so this is a huge benefit, in my opinion. The NVIDIA RTX 2070 Super is a mid-range graphics card, and more than capable of most engineering tasks. The graphics card is overkill for all but the most complex PCBs in Altium Designer, and sufficient for moderate to high complexity mechanical CAD products.
Which Computer for CAD Design is Best for You?Weve looked at ten computers for CAD design and engineering over a range of performance categories and a variety of budgets. If youre looking for the best computer to run Altium Designer, anything on this list will meet your requirements. I would suggest looking at options with 32GB of RAM or more if your budget can accommodate that. When I polled my community of Altium Designer users, typically Altium Designer was using around 1.5-5GB of RAM. However, almost every person was using more than 16GB of RAM on their computer due to other applications - particularly web browsers and datasheets. Having less than 16GB of RAM on your system could hurt your performance, meaning that you cannot make the best use of the hardware youve just purchased. Suppose youre looking for the best SolidWorks computer. In that case, it really likes having an NVIDIA Quadro card, and even the lowest specification Quadro will enable some functionality such as RealView despite other graphics cards being substantially higher performance. The best computer for Autodesk Inventor/Fusion360 could be any computer from this list.Again having enough RAM in your computer makes a big difference for CAD and engineering tasks. I was quite impressed with the system configuration builder that Origin offers, so if you are in North America, then one of their systems might provide you with exactly what you need no matter the budget. The MSI Prestige P100 offers great value for money, in my opinion, and would be an ideal computer for many engineering uses. While you may be looking for a pre-built computer that is ready to use, you might also consider having a local computer store build you a computer to your requirements. The cost is likely to be lower than some of the large brands on this list, and a small computer store will highly value your business. Take a look at my article Build the Best CAD Computer for 2020 for some ideas of specifications. Would you like to find out more about how Altium can help you with your next PCB design? Talk to an expert at Altium.All product names, company names, and images are trademarks or registered® trademarks of their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by any other company. |